| GC writes: Terrence Deacon in The Symbolic Species suggests we've got
a massive
over capacity to create symbols, ikons, images of what might be. But first things first; food shelter and shoes for the children; but that done and with no wars to fight and no coal to dig we've nothing better to do than build careers or be wealth creators. Paradically we cooperate with each other to subsist, only to compete
when the real
p 434 "Preoccupied as we are with ends, in all senses of the word, we organise our actions around imagined extrapolations of the consequences they will produce; we weave marvellously elaborate and beautifully obscure stories to find purpose in our lives.
The price we pay for this is that our symbolically mediated actions can often be in conflict with motivations to act that arise from more concrete and immediate biological sources. Our compulsions to act that rise from purely or mediated physiological sources could be called bottom up processes for producing action; these are comparitively predictable. But symbolically mediated compulsions are far more (chaotic and) susceptical to the influence of tiny initial differences in starting assumptions or ways of dividing up experiences and qualities symbolically - this because symbolically mediated models of things, whether theories, stories or just rationally argued predictions all exhibit complicated non linearity and resursive structure as well as nearly infinite flexibility and capacity for novelty due to their combinitorial nature. Little of our reasoning is so precise as to be called deductive yet the way that certain beliefs compel others can have nearly this force. Ideologies, religions and just good explanations thus exert a sort of inferential compulsion on us that it is hard to resist because of their mutually reinforcing deductive and inductive links. Our end directed behaviours are in this way often derived from such "compulsions" One might say that thinking in symbols is a means whereby formal causes can determine final causes. The abstract nature of this source makes for a top down causality, even if implemented on a bottom up biological machine." There is the considerable tension between the top down and bottom up states of mind. The one speculative and arrogant, the other biological and humane.. . |
| Problem inherent in too much mebo...can't find anyone whose mebo map
matches ours
hence either disappointment = heart ache which we can live with OR the idea that our own mebo collection = us since our sense of identity is made of them ..are superior and hence we try to push square holes etc and all the machinations of who knows best etc |